A 14-year-old deaf dog named Gemma remains missing after doorbell camera footage allegedly showed Fay Marie Nihart leaving the senior animal outside a Cedar Rapids, Iowa, home and closing the door behind her. The dog’s family believes she was deliberately let out during a dispute involving Nihart and her former boyfriend. With Gemma unable to hear people calling her or approaching danger, rescuers are urging residents to check security cameras and report sightings immediately.
The disappearance of Gemma, a senior tan-and-white dog wearing a pink collar, has sparked widespread anger and concern after footage of the incident circulated across social media. The dog was reportedly last seen near Everlou Road and Beverly Road in southwest Cedar Rapids, close to the Cedar Rapids-Fairfax area.
According to posts shared by people involved in the search, Gemma disappeared on Monday, November 16, 2026, at approximately 11 p.m. She is 14 years old, deaf and described by her family as non-aggressive.
Fay Marie Nihart has been accused of intentionally letting Gemma outside during a bitter breakup dispute. The allegation was shared by people identifying themselves as connected to the dog’s owner, Bryan Lee, who reportedly said his former partner had deliberately released the animal.
The accusation has not resulted in a publicly confirmed criminal charge, and Nihart has not been convicted of an offense. However, the doorbell footage and the family’s account have intensified calls for an investigation and an urgent effort to locate Gemma.
Doorbell Camera Footage Shows Gemma Left Outside
Video circulating online appears to show a blonde woman wearing a white tank top and dark trousers opening the door of a brightly lit porch at night. Gemma can be seen standing nearby, looking toward the woman.
The woman is heard saying, “Bye. Bye. See ya,” before walking away and closing the door.
Gemma remains outside for a moment, looking around and barking toward the street. She then walks down the steps and disappears into the dark yard.
The footage has been shared by several social media accounts, including MamaX_5, Tommy Gauthier, Lakizzy Tell Stories and Marcella Bradet. MamaX_5, a creator who regularly posts crime-related and viral stories, helped bring attention to Gemma’s disappearance.
One widely circulated version reportedly attracted more than 721,000 views, 47,000 likes and thousands of comments in less than a day.
An important distinction has emerged in discussions about the footage: the video does not show the woman physically picking up and throwing Gemma. Rather, it appears to show the dog being left outside before the door is closed. The allegation is that this was intentional abandonment, not that the dog was physically thrown.
Family Says Gemma Was Deliberately Let Out During Relationship Dispute
The circumstances surrounding Gemma’s disappearance have been described as particularly upsetting because of the alleged connection to a relationship dispute.
Bryan Lee, who has identified himself as Gemma’s owner, reportedly posted that his former partner intentionally let the dog outside. A message circulated alongside the video also described the woman as the owner’s uncle’s ex and asked the public to help find the missing animal.
MamaX_5 characterized the incident as the result of a romantic disagreement, while other posts accused Nihart of using the dog to hurt her former boyfriend.
Those claims remain allegations. The available footage shows the woman leaving Gemma outside, but it does not independently establish the motive behind the incident.
For Gemma’s family and the people searching for her, the immediate concern is finding the elderly dog before she encounters further danger.
Why Gemma’s Deafness Makes the Search Especially Urgent
Gemma’s age and hearing impairment make her disappearance particularly concerning.
At 14, she is a senior dog who cannot hear people calling her name, approaching vehicles, trains or other animals. Although she can still rely on sight, smell and physical vibrations, unfamiliar surroundings can make it difficult for her to recognize danger or respond to people trying to help.
Her family has described her as non-aggressive and warned that she may become frightened if strangers approach too quickly.
Rescuers are therefore asking anyone who spots Gemma not to chase her. Instead, people should remain calm, avoid sudden movements and contact the rescue organization with her exact location and direction of travel.
The missing-dog appeal also asks residents around Everlou Road, Beverly Road and the surrounding Fairfax area to review doorbell and security-camera recordings, particularly footage from the night of November 16.
Paws of Hope Animal Rescue Issues Missing-Dog Appeal
Paws of Hope Animal Rescue has been identified as a key contact in the search for Gemma.
An urgent missing-dog notice describes her as a deaf, 14-year-old tan-and-white dog who disappeared near Everlou Road in Cedar Rapids. She was wearing a pink collar when last seen.
The notice asks residents to watch their properties, check security cameras and report any possible sightings.
The organization has also warned people to be cautious of strangers in comment sections offering supposedly specialized pet-tracking services. People searching for Gemma have been advised to work through local shelters and verified rescue organizations rather than sending money to unknown accounts.
Anyone with information about Gemma’s whereabouts is asked to call or text Paws of Hope Animal Rescue at 319-929-2945.

Social Media Users React With Anger and Concern
The footage has prompted strong reactions from viewers, many of whom have focused on Gemma’s age and inability to hear.
One commenter wrote, “She better be charged. How evil.”
Another asked, “Oh my God. How can you do this to an innocent, deaf baby?”
Others expressed concern about the possibility of Gemma wandering near roads or unfamiliar areas without being able to hear approaching danger.
“And deaf… That’s scary. She won’t be able to hear danger coming,” one person wrote.
Another viewer pleaded for an update, saying they could not imagine how frightened the dog might be.
MamaX_5 reportedly responded to concerned viewers by saying Gemma had not yet been found and that drone searches were being considered as part of the effort to locate her.
The reaction has continued as users share the footage, circulate the missing-dog notice and encourage residents in the search area to look out for the senior animal.
What Iowa Law Says About Abandoning a Dog
The allegations have also prompted calls for authorities to investigate whether Gemma was intentionally abandoned.
Iowa Code Section 717B.8 addresses the abandonment of cats and dogs. It prohibits a person who owns or has custody of an animal from relinquishing their responsibilities without making an appropriate arrangement, such as transferring the animal to someone willing to accept custody or delivering it to an animal shelter or pound.
The law provides for different levels of misdemeanor penalties depending on whether abandonment results in no injury, injury or more serious harm or death.
Iowa also has separate animal-cruelty and neglect provisions. Whether any particular law applies to Gemma’s disappearance would depend on the evidence and the findings of an investigation.
The online petition concerning the case calls on Cedar Rapids police to investigate the alleged abandonment, assist with efforts to locate Gemma and consider appropriate charges if the evidence supports them.
At the time of the circulating reports, no confirmed criminal charge against Nihart had been announced.
Gemma Remains Missing as Community Search Continues
The search for Gemma has continued through social media appeals, local volunteers and requests for nearby residents to check surveillance footage.
Her last reported location is around Everlou Road and Beverly Road in southwest Cedar Rapids, Iowa. She is described as a 14-year-old deaf, tan-and-white dog who was wearing a pink collar.
Anyone who sees a dog matching Gemma’s description is urged not to chase or frighten her. The safest response is to keep a distance, observe where she goes and immediately contact Paws of Hope Animal Rescue.
Paws of Hope Animal Rescue: 319-929-2945
For the people looking for Gemma, the priority remains bringing her home safely. Every credible sighting could help narrow the search for a senior dog who cannot hear the people calling for her.
